Targeted direct mail
If your aim is to connect with a specific and well-suited audience, targeted direct mail is an effective marketing strategy to explore. Suppose your intended audience includes real estate agents, high-income homeowners, and avid golfers. In that case, targeted direct mail can help you reach out to them through customized mailing lists that filter by geographical area and other relevant criteria.
By selecting a smaller and more focused audience, you can save on printing and postage costs while enhancing your response rate. This approach helps you avoid wasting resources on sending mail to individuals who are unlikely to be interested in your product or service, thereby increasing the likelihood of converting leads into customers.
To take advantage of targeted direct mail, you can share your customer data with Sir Speedy, a leading printing and marketing services company. Our team will work with you to develop a targeted mailing list that aligns with your business goals and objectives. With this tailored approach, you can effectively reach your desired audience and achieve your desired outcomes.
Reach the Right Customers—Right in Their Mailboxes
Turn nearby households and businesses into new customers with targeted direct mail that gets noticed, remembered, and acted on.
Sir Speedy is your one-stop print and mail partner, managing everything from audience targeting and creative design to printing, postage, and delivery. No juggling multiple vendors. No wondering who has the mailing list. Just one local team keeping your campaign, and your sanity, on track.
Identify Your Ideal Customer for Direct Mailing
Great direct mail starts with one deceptively simple question: Who should receive it? Begin by defining your primary audience. Depending on your business, that could include homeowners, renters, families, retirees, business owners, recent movers, or customers within a particular income range.
Sir Speedy can help you refine your audience using:
- Geographic targeting by ZIP Code, neighborhood, radius, or carrier route
- Demographic criteria such as age, income, household size, or homeownership
- Behavioral indicators, interests, purchasing patterns, or life events
- Existing point-of-sale or CRM customer data
- Lookalike audiences based on your best current customers
The sharper the target, the less money you spend introducing your offer to people who were never likely to respond.
Plan a Direct Mail Marketing Campaign
Before choosing paper stock or debating whether the headline needs an exclamation point, establish what the campaign should accomplish.
Set a clear objective, such as generating appointments, attracting customers to a grand opening, increasing repeat purchases, promoting a seasonal service, or introducing your business to a new neighborhood.
Next, define the campaign’s start and end dates, mail format, primary offer, total budget, and spending caps. You should also determine the mailing quantity and frequency, geographic coverage, and key performance indicators.
Useful KPIs may include response rate, website visits, phone calls, appointments, redemptions, sales, or revenue per mailed piece. Clear goals help guide every later decision—and prevent the campaign from becoming an expensive exercise in “Well, we mailed some things.”
Direct Mail Design and Print Options
Your format should match your message, budget, and desired customer action.
Postcards
Postcards are affordable, immediate, and easy to scan. They work well for promotions, events, appointment reminders, new-business introductions, and limited-time offers.
Brochures
Brochures provide more room to explain services, showcase benefits, and feature multiple products. They are a strong choice when customers need additional information before acting.
Booklets
Booklets are ideal for catalogs, detailed service guides, product collections, menus, or premium campaigns that require more storytelling space.
Once you select a format, consider paper weight, finish, coating, durability, and mailing requirements. A glossy coating can make colors pop, while an uncoated stock may feel warmer and easier to write on.
Sir Speedy can provide design templates and format recommendations based on your campaign. Before production begins, you will have an opportunity to review and approve a proof, so names, dates, prices, phone numbers, and offers are correct.
Design Templates and Best Practices
Direct mail has only a few seconds to earn attention, so make those seconds count.
Follow the correct size, trim, safety area, and bleed guidelines for your selected format. Keep important text away from the edges and leave appropriate space for addressing and postal markings.
To create a stronger design, lead with a short, high-contrast headline and focus on one primary message. Use relevant images instead of decorative clutter and make the offer easy to understand. Include one clear call to action and add an expiration date when urgency is appropriate. Repeat essential contact information and make QR codes large enough to scan easily.
When everything is emphasized, nothing stands out. Give the reader one obvious next step, such as calling, visiting, scanning, scheduling, ordering, or redeeming.
Mailing Lists, Targeting, and EDDM Choices
A targeted list lets you select recipients using specific demographic, geographic, or behavioral criteria. This approach works well when your ideal customer has clearly defined characteristics or when you want to reach named individuals and businesses.
Mailing data can be purchased, appended to existing records, or built from your CRM and point-of-sale systems. Before mailing, addresses should be standardized and validated to improve deliverability. Duplicate, outdated, undeliverable, and known do-not-mail records should also be removed when applicable.
Better data means fewer wasted pieces, and fewer postcards attempting to sell landscaping services to an empty lot.
EDDM Versus Targeted Mailing Guidance
Every Door Direct Mail can be a practical option when nearly everyone in a chosen neighborhood could be a potential customer. Restaurants, home-service companies, healthcare offices, retailers, and community organizations often use it to build broad local awareness.
With EDDM, you can map eligible carrier routes and deliver to qualifying addresses along those routes without purchasing a traditional name-and-address list.
A targeted list may be the stronger choice when you need to reach households with specific demographic characteristics, contact selected businesses or decision-makers, personalize pieces for each recipient, or mail to current or former customers. It also allows you to suppress existing customers or other records and focus your campaign on a narrower, higher-value audience.
Sir Speedy can compare estimated reach, postage, production costs, and targeting precision to help you choose the best approach. EDDM may reduce certain data and postage costs, while a targeted list can reduce waste by concentrating your campaign on the households most likely to respond.
Campaign Tracking, Measurement, and Optimization
Direct mail should be measurable. Assign each campaign, or each version within a campaign, a unique response method.
You can track responses by using unique promotional or coupon codes, campaign-specific QR codes, dedicated phone numbers, unique website URLs, personalized URLs (PURLs), campaign landing pages, or in-store redemption codes.
Measure each campaign’s response rate, conversion rate, cost per lead, cost per acquisition, average order value, and overall return on investment.
For ongoing campaigns, test one meaningful variable at a time. You might compare two headlines, offers, designs, audiences, or calls to action. A/B testing helps replace opinions with evidence—which is useful when everyone in the meeting is suddenly a headline expert.
Get Started with Your Targeted Direct Mail Campaign
Ready to reach more customers without managing a small parade of printers, designers, data vendors, and postal paperwork?
Book a free consultation with your local Sir Speedy team. We will help you define your audience, select the right mailing approach, develop your creative, and coordinate production through delivery.
Request a custom campaign estimate today—and put your next offer directly into the hands of the people most likely to act on it.
Jack Doyle
Working with Sir Speedy was one of the best decisions our company has made. We placed an order for training manuals to be made and they were nothing but professional. Their ability to communicate and follow up with our order allowed us to move smoothly without ever wondering where it was in the process. Their online services allowed us to edit and make changes as needed. We would highly recommend working with them for any print or marketing needs!
Ross Levtow
I was absolutely blown away by this company from the moment I walked in. The offices are beautiful, modern, and incredibly welcoming, and the facility itself is spotless. You can immediately tell they take pride in everything they do. The owner (Evan) is one of the nicest, most honest, and caring people you'll ever meet. It's rare to find a business that combines outstanding customer service with such a high level of professionalism. The factory is brand new, impressively large, and unbelievably clean. Seeing all of the samples and capabilities firsthand was eye-opening-they truly do it all. The attention to detail and quality of work is second to none. I have clients that have old reception desks or boring entry places for their offices. They have beautiful applications to transform your boring spaces to the most gorgeous custom eye-catching pieces. I left extremely impressed and confident that I found a company I can trust. I will absolutely be using them in the future, referring friends, family, and clients, and even considering them for projects at my own home. If you're looking for a printing company on Long Island that delivers quality, professionalism, and integrity, look no further. Highly recommended!
Jeane Miller
For our recent project, we needed custom poster boards within 2 business days for an important meeting and Sir Speedy of Bethpage truly delivered as usual! Highly recommend them for all your printing needs!
Joseph Salamone
We have used Sir Speedy for our signage needs for the last 10 years. Evan and his team are second to none. They are attentive, extremely FAST and are always willing to go the extra mile. I remember one time - and in all these years it really has been just ONE time when there was an issue with one of the signs that we needed for a major event. Evan jumped through hoops to have it resolved within the same day without issue. You do not find that level of customer service and satisfaction in many places today. I cannot recommend them enough.
Jenna Natale
I've been partnering with Sir Speedy for nearly a decade across 2 different organizations. Without a doubt, they're the gold standard. From complex signage, to last-minute add-on requests, to a team that has caught errors that have gotten past my own highly-skilled creative teams... Evan Bloom and his team are THE go-to for top quality products, executed and delivered quickly and professionally. My favorite Sir Speedy anecdote: I once opened a corporate sponsorship sign at the venue ~5hrs before event day and realized my design team made a critical error. Evan's team hand-delivered a revised product to my team before cocktail hour. UNREAL! As I wrote simply in my last email to them (in which I asked for an extended deadline, and they replied, "You know we'll get it done for you." They will.): "My love and admiration for Sir Speedy is boundless... you da bomb, guys."
Allison D'elia-Hall
We extremely appreciate all of the hard work that Michele, Brandon, Amy, and Junior put in for a recent order. We needed it with a quick turnaround, and it arrived in perfect time. We were more than thrilled with the final product, and it worked out perfectly at our recent event that we needed to use them for. Sir Speedy is my preferred vendor to work with because of how successful all of my print pieces have been with them. Super awesome work!
Brittany Mayoka
We had a great experience ! The quality of the work was excellent, communication was clear throughout the process, and everything was delivered exactly as promised. The final result elevated the look and feel of our space and aligned perfectly with our brand. We would absolutely recommend them and look forward to working together again.
Allison Storck
I value and appreciate Sir Speedy's partnership, professionalism and timely manner in turning projects around. I'd highly recommend working with them for all your printing needs.
Katie
Sir Speedy is the best and most reliable printing service on Long Island. They produce the highest quality materials and have very good pricing, plus their customer service cannot be beat! I rely on them for all of my printing needs for many years now and they have never let me down!
Marisa Orlich
Evan and his team delivered quality service and products. Their feedback was incredibly helpful while I was putting together time sensitive marketing material for an event. They were communitive on realistic products that could printed in my time frame. I am beyond happy with the promotional flyers they printed for me.
Caitlin Fine
Everyone I worked with at Sir Speedy was incredibly helpful and efficient. As soon as we got off the phone and sent over the full project details, they quickly provided a quote and an impressive turnaround time. The magnetic graphics turned out great - now I see why "Speedy" is in their name!
Marc Horowitz
We have just completed our third product order in as many months and have been totally happy with the end results. You can always count on Sir Speedy to fulfill what they promise to do for you!
Preston Hemann
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Exceptional Service, Professionalism, and Results – Highly Recommended! I can’t speak highly enough about the team at Sir Speedy of Bethpage, NY—especially Rich and Evan. Their professionalism, attentiveness, and work quality were outstanding. We had a high-profile, time-sensitive project involving four tractor trailers for a major logistics account supporting the **DP World Tour and Ryder Cup**. Each truck required full decal removal, redesign, printing, and reapplication—**all within 48 hours**. Despite being located in North Carolina (Pristine Wraps Co.), we confidently handed this project off to Rich and Evan, and they handled everything remotely with flawless execution. From start to finish, they communicated clearly, worked efficiently, and delivered **ahead of schedule**. The quality of the finished work was top-tier and exceeded all expectations. If you're in the New York area and need ; graphics, advertising, or design, Sir Speedy Bethpage is the only name you need to know. These guys are elite—**5 stars all day**.
katie healy
Sir Speedy has consistently been the most reliable printer I have ever worked with. Their work is flawless and well- priced. Their customer service is the absolute best. I have recommended them countless times and will continue to do so. They are truly a graphic designer best friend!
Allison Norris
Evan Bloom and his team are very experienced and professional- quotes and proofs are all delivered in a timely manner. The creativity, quality and presentation are always amazing and the product turnaround is, as their name suggests, speedy! Customer service is always responsive and helpful, making sure the client is satisfied.
LILAC
Brandon Bloom and his team are always professional and live up to the name of Sir "Speedy"! Their polite and positive interactions with their clients, as well at the quality of the products, is what keeps our organization coming back.
Fabrizio Salerno
Excellent Service! My package was expected to be delivered when it was raining, and they expedited the process so it was hand-delivered and on time before the weather got bad! Thank you, Evan, Brandon, and the team!
Brenna Cicciari
Team was very responsive and helpful with all of my questions. The process was smooth and easy from start to finish. Will definitely work with again!
CG
I had an outstanding experience with this company. They fulfilled my printing request with remarkable speed and attention to detail. Their professionalism and quality of work exceeded my expectations. I highly recommend them for all your printing needs!
Eric Pallay
Our merch was excellent. High quality and, in a conference with 30,000 attendees, stood out amongst other free giveaways. Thanks! The team at Sir Speedy are fantastic. Attention to detail, quick to respond and a pleasure to work with.
BELYNDA WESTEN
Highly recommend!!! From start to finish, the entire process was seamless! I am not only thrilled with the product they provided but the huge amount of money they saved me as well. Sentry will definitely be a return customer for sure! Thank you so much!
dada p
Gumuchian have been a client over 5 years and there is a very good reason for that. We were completely impressed with Michele Cacioppo, Brandon Bloom and team professionalism and customer service. The product quality is consistently outstanding, exceeding our expectations every time. Pricing is fair and transparent, value for money. Efficiency and punctuality are hallmarks of their service. I highly recommend Sir Speedy
Shawn Jarrett
Thanks for another great project, this one was a little unique, and you rolled with it perfectly! Sir Speedy is our "go-to" printer! They are always so accommodating with any task we throw their way. These guys are the best!!
Kristin Motschwiller
Sir Speedy has great customer service, truly speedy production times, and a great communication system. I was referred to Sir Speedy by a different printing business that was unable to fulfill my request due to what I needed done, and I DEFINITELY recommend Sir Speedy!!! Thank you!!
Kathy Caldarola
Long Island Housing Partnership has always had wonderful experience working with Sir Speedy and will happily continue to use their services!
Edward Bullard
The Bullard Law Group has used Sir Speedy for all of our printed products for many years (envelopes, letterhead, door signs). They are responsive and always make sure our projects are accurate. It is a pleasure working with a family run business that treats every client like their most important client.
Leanne Warshauer
Excellent customer service and a great product. The team at Sir Speedy is always so helpful in making sure what they print for us looks as good as possible, even fixing our file when needed.
Angeline Perry
It was a pleasure working with Sir Speedy, they got what I needed done in a timely fashion and with complete professionalism and follow up. I wouldn’t go anywhere else for my business needs now that I found Sir Speedy in Westbury. Google
Angela Frodella
Our company deals with the Westbury/now Bethpage location for years. Michele Cacioppo is wonderful, always a pleasure to work with --very professional and so helpful when deciding on sizing and paper finishes. Brandon was great too in customer service and sending out invoicing in a timely manner. Always love doing business with them.
Jean Johnston
We had 15 year old custom interior signs in our medical office; Sir Speedy did a great job of matching the colors, design and texture when we needed to add signs for new providers in the office.
Ander Durio
Recently placed an order with this company and was extremely impressed with the quick delivery and outstanding customer service. Not only did my order arrive promptly, but the customer service was incredibly helpful and responsive to my inquiries. I highly recommend this company to anyone looking for hassle-free shopping experience. Will definitely be a returning customer!
Sales Reviews
Evan at Sir Speedy is the best! He is attentive and informative and always responds in a timely manner. We use Sir Speedy for our envelopes and they are always on time and look great.
Vickey Ronen
The staff was very attentive and buttoned up. I received a proof every time I made a change to the job. Sir Speedy made "fun money" for our company holiday party. The final product was awesome and delivered on time! I will use them again for future projects! Thank you!
Taylor Scibilia
Maria and team are so awesome to work with! They were super accommodating with all proof requests, and everything was done in a speedy ;) fashion. Love working with them, and our pens came out great!
Maria Soto
Sir Speedy always does great work for us at our office. You can rest assured that you will get quality results and in a timely fashion. Customer service is also great! Thank you!
Natoya Curd
I have had the honor of teaming up with Sir Speedy for numerous years, and our partnership has been nothing short of exceptional. No matter the project, they prioritize it and consistently deliver outstanding customer service and top-notch products. They have even come to my rescue in several tight spots, for which I am incredibly grateful. I'm eagerly looking forward to continuing our partnership for years to come.
Sir Speedy Bethpage
Suite 1250
Bethpage, NY 11714
Business Hours
- Monday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
- Tuesday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
- Wednesday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
- Thursday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
- Friday: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
- Saturday: Closed
- Sunday: Closed
- Phone number: 516-334-7400
- Email: [email protected]
- Directions
